Did the US annexation of Puerto Rico in 1898 increase the biological standard of living of its population?A first anthropometric approach

  1. Javier Moreno Lázaro 1
  1. 1 Universidad de Valladolid
    info

    Universidad de Valladolid

    Valladolid, España

    ROR https://ror.org/01fvbaw18

Journal:
Documentos de trabajo de la Asociación Española de Historia Económica

Year of publication: 2024

Issue: 24

Type: Working paper

DIALNET GOOGLE SCHOLAR lock_openOpen access editor

Abstract

This paper hypothesises that the annexation of Puerto Rico by the United States in 1898 led to a decline in material well-being, as measured by individual height, that lasted for the first three decades of the twentieth century. To demonstrate this, a significant sample has been created made up of the height of males born in Puerto Rico between 1877 and 1929 who were enlisted in the army between 1940 and 1947. In order to make the relevant comparisons a second sample with the heights of California residents has also been created. The results of the calculations show a sharp decline in the height of Puerto Ricans, both in relative and absolute terms. This deterioration was due to the shortcomings of the public policies implemented by the US government, which failed to improve the working, food, health and residential conditions of Puerto Ricans. In addition, they suffered the social costs of the price of sugar on the world market as well as those inherent in the late adoption of industrial capitalism. These results call into question the indolence of Spanish colonialism and highlight the difficulties of emerging US colonialism in generating welfare in the territories it occupied

Bibliographic References

  • Alemán Iglesias, J. 2018. El origen del colono en Puerto Rico. Un balance historiográfico del agricultor de la industria azucarera en el siglo XX. Revista de Indias 78, (273): 533- 560.
  • Amador, J. 2015. Medicine and nation building in the Americas, 1890-1940. Nashville: Van-debitt University Press
  • Ashford, B.K. 1923. Unicianariasis. El libro de Puerto Rico ed. Fernández García, E. 336- 369. San Juan. El Libro Azul.
  • Ayala, C.J. and Begard, L.W. 2000. Agrarian Puerto Rico. Reconsidering rural economy and society, 1899-1940. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  • Baten,J., Pelger, I., and Twrdek, L. 2009. The anthropometric history of Argentina, Brazil and Peru during the 19th and early 20th century. Economics and Human Biology 7: 319- 333
  • Begard, L.W. 1983. Coffe and rural proletarianization, 1840-1898. Journal of Latin American Studies 15 (1): 83-100
  • Bondenhorn, H., Guinnene, T.W., Mroz. T. 2019. Theory and diagnostics for selection biases in historical height samples. Research in Economic History 35: 59-89.
  • Brau, S. 1889. Las clases jornaleras de Puerto Rico. San Juan: Imprenta del “Boletín Mercantil”
  • Carlo Alitieri, G.A. 2009. Derecho y esclavitud en el Puerto Rico del siglo XIX. Op. Cit. 6 (7): 91-117.
  • Carroll, H. K. 1899. Report of the island of Porto Rico. Washington: Government Printing Office.
  • Crist, R. E. 1948. Sugar cane and coffee in Puerto Rico, II: The pauperization of the jíbaro. Land Monopoly and Monoculture. The American Journal of Economics and Sociology 7 (3): 321-337
  • Crosby, W.H. 1987. The deadly hookworm: why did the Puerto Ricans die? Archives of . International Medicine 147 (3): 577-78.
  • Enamorado Cuesta, J. 1975. Puerto Rico, past and present. New York: Arnold Press.
  • Fernández, E. 1923. El problema de la tuberculosis en Puerto Rico, ed. Fernández García, E. El libro de Puerto Rico, 356-365. San Juan: El Libro Azul.
  • Fernós, A. 1923. Higiene escolar en Puerto Rico, ed. Fernández García, E. El libro de Puerto Rico, 344-347. San Juan: El Libro Azul.
  • Font, E. Desenvolvimiento sanitario. Instrucción. La junta de Sanidad. Fernández García, ed. Fernández García, E. El libro de Puerto Rico, 286-304. San Juan: El Libro Azul.
  • Godoy, R.A., Goodman, E. Levins, E. Caram, M. and Seifried, C. 2007. Adult male height in an American colony: Puerto Rico and the USA mainland compared, 1886–1955. Economics and Human Biology 5 (1): 82-99.
  • Governor of Porto Rico, 1909. Annual report for the fiscal year ending June 30. Washington: Government Printing.
  • Gutiérrez Igaravidez, P., King, W.W. and Ashford., B.K.1906. Informe preliminar de la comisión para la supresión de la anemia en Puerto Rico. Washington . Bureau of Printing and Supplies.
  • Komlos, J., Baten, J. 2004. Looking backward and looking forward: anthropometric research and the development of social science history. Social Science History 2.191– 210.
  • Lavandero, P. Puericultura. ed. Fernández García, E. El libro de Puerto Rico, 340-344. San Juan: El Libro Azul.
  • Llorca-Jana, M., Araya, R. and Navarrete Montalvo, J. 2018. Antropometría histórica de Chile: evolución de la estatura de la población en el largo plazo, siglos XVIII-XX. Estudios Atacameños. Arqueología y Antropología Surandinas. 60: 161-191.
  • López-Alonso, M. 2010. Living standards of the Mexican laboring classes, 1850-1950; An Anthropometric approach. Living standards in Latin American history. Height, welfare and development, Salvatore, eds. R. D., Coastworth, J. and Challú , A. E. 69- 103. Harvard University. Cambridge.
  • Meaisel, A. and Vega, M. 2010. Stature of the Colombian Elite before de onset of industrialization, 1870-1919. Living standards in Latin American history. Height, welfare and development, Salvatore, eds. R. D., Coastworth, J. and Challú , A. E. 105-126. Harvard University. Cambridge.
  • Marein, B. 2020. Economic development in Puerto Rico after US annexation: Anthropometric evidence. Economics and Human Biology 38 :100892.
  • Marein, B. y Devereux, J. 2024. A comment on “Height and the standard of living in Puerto Rico from the Spanish Enlightenment to annexation by the United States, 1770– 1924”. Economics & Human Biology 53:101376-
  • Martínez Carrión, J.M. y Salvatore, R. D. 2019. Inequality and well-being in Iberian and Latin American regions since 1820. New approaches from anthropometric history. Revista de Historia Económica = Journal of Iberian and Latin American Economic History 37, 2: pp. 193-204.
  • Monasterio, L. M. (2013). Estatura e inmigración en el sur de Brasil, 1889-1914. América Latina en la Historia Económica 21(11). 115-133.
  • Moreno-Lázaro, J. 2023. Height and standard of living in Puerto Rico from the Spanish enlightenment to the annexation by the United States, 1770-1924. Economics and Human Biology 49 3:101243.
  • Picó, F. 1982. Libertad y servidumbre en el Puerto Rico del siglo XIX. San Juan: Ediciones Huracán. San Juan.
  • Plante, T. K. 2007. Military service records at National Archives. Washington: National Archives and Records Administration.
  • Pumarada, L. 1990. La industria cafetalera de Puerto Rico, 1736-1969. San Juan: Oficina Estatal de la Preservación Histórica.
  • Ramírez de Arellano, R.W. 1932. Los huracanes en Puerto Rico. Río Piedras: Universidad de Puerto Rico.
  • Ramírez, G.A. 1923. Historia de la ingeniería sanitaria. Fernández García, ed. Fernández García, E. El libro de Puerto Rico, 310-327. San Juan: El Libro Azul.
  • Rigau Pérez, J. C. 2009-10. El Servicio de Salud Pública de los Estados Unidos en Puerto Rico, 1898-1918. Op. Cit. 19. 143-177.
  • Salvatore R. 2019. The biological wellbeing of the working-poor: the height of prisoners in Buenos Aires Province, Argentina, 1885–1939. Economic and Human Biology 34(1): 92–102.
  • Salvatore, R. 2007- Heights, nutrition and well-being in Argentina, ca. 1850–1950. 2007. Preliminary results. Revista de Historia Económica. 25 (1): 53-86
  • Sanger, S.P. (ed.). 1899. Informe del Censo de Puerto Rico. Washington: Imprenta del Gobierno.
  • Sardá, A. 1889. La isla de Puerto Rico. Estudio histórico y geográfico. Madrid: Establecimiento Tipográfico de Evaristo Esteban.
  • Sierra García, P. 1923. Estado actual del obrero fabril portorriqueño. Fernández García, ed. Fernández García, E. El libro de Puerto Rico, 770-744.. San Juan: El Libro Azul.
  • Steckel, R. H. 2009. Heights and human welfare: recent developments and new directions”. Explorations in Economic History 46 (1) 1-23.
  • Steckel, R. H. and Floud, R. 1997. Health and Welfare during Industrialization. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
  • Steckel, R., 1995. Stature and the Standard of Living. Journal of Economic Literature 33 (4): 1903-40.
  • Trujillo-Pagán, N. 2013. Modern colonization by medical intervention: US medicine in Puerto Rico. Liden: Brill.
  • US Department of Commerce, 1975. Historical statistics of the US from colonial times to 1970. Washington: Bureau of Census.
  • Valle Artiles, F. 1885. El campesino puertorriqueño. Sus condiciones físicas, intelectuales y morales. Causas que la determinan y medios para mejorarlas. San Juan: Tipografía de Font.
  • Vázquez, J.L. 1964. La población de Puerto Rico. San Juan: Universidad de Puerto Rico.
  • Von R. Hoff. 1901a. Abridgment of the Charity Broad of Porto Rico. Washington: Government Printing Office.
  • Von R. Hoff. 1901b. Report of the Superior Broad of Head of Porto Rico. Washington: Government Printing Office.
  • Zeno, F.; M. 1923. El obrero agrícola como factor de progreso Fernández García, E. ed. Fernández García, E. El libro de Puerto Rico, 736-739 .. San Juan: El Libro Azul.
Data source: Dialnet